Ohio State's Transfer Portal Dilemma: Are the Buckeyes Falling Behind?
The college football transfer portal has been open for 10 days, and while Ohio State has secured seven potential starters, some glaring roster holes remain unfilled. But here's where it gets controversial: is Ohio State's patient approach to the portal a strategic move or a risky gamble? Let’s dive into the positions where the Buckeyes are still scrambling and explore why their strategy might be both a blessing and a curse.
The Clock is Ticking: Unfilled Positions
Kicker: Yes, you read that right. Ohio State doesn’t have a single kicker on their 2026 roster. After losing Jackson Courville to the portal, the Buckeyes are in desperate need of a proven kicker who can nail 50-yard field goals and deliver in clutch moments. But with no clear target in sight, fans are left wondering: Is this a position they’re willing to gamble on?
Cornerback: With only two experienced cornerbacks returning, Ohio State needs at least two more to fill out their depth chart. The Buckeyes struck out on Auburn’s Kayin Lee and Maryland’s La’Khi Roland, both of whom signed with Tennessee. This leaves them in a precarious position, especially after losing key players like Davison Igbinosun and Lorenzo Styles Jr. Are they waiting for the perfect fit, or are they risking being left behind?
Defensive End: While Kenyatta Jackson Jr.’s potential return eases some pressure, Ohio State still needs another edge defender with experience. Former Penn State standout Chaz Coleman slipped through their fingers, signing with Tennessee. Alabama’s Qua Russaw is a possibility, but he’s more of a hybrid linebacker. Is Ohio State aiming too high, or are they missing out on solid options?
The Strategy: Patient or Passive?
Ohio State has always taken a deliberate approach to the transfer portal, but this year’s strategy feels different. With 28 scholarship players lost to the portal—the most in Buckeyes history—they’ve been more prudent about who they pursue and how much they offer. This has led to them being outbid for top targets like Coleman. But is this a wise long-term strategy, or are they sacrificing immediate needs for future flexibility?
Controversial Take: Some argue that Ohio State’s reluctance to engage in bidding wars for top transfers could cost them a shot at a national championship in 2026. Others believe their focus on retaining stars like Jeremiah Smith and Julian Sayin, along with a strong incoming freshman class, positions them for sustained success. What do you think? Are the Buckeyes playing it too safe, or are they building a foundation for the future?
Positions of Opportunity
Defensive Tackle: The addition of UCF’s John Walker was a solid move, but Ohio State could still use another transfer to round out their two-deep. Alabama’s James Smith and Pittsburgh’s Francis Brewu are strong options, but will the Buckeyes land either of them?
Wide Receiver: UTSA’s Devin McCuin adds experience, but depth remains a concern. Are the Buckeyes done at this position, or will they make a late push for another veteran receiver?
Safety: With Earl Little Jr. and Terry Moore on board, safety is less of a priority, but additional depth wouldn’t hurt. Is this a position they’re overlooking?
The Final Whistle
Ohio State’s transfer portal strategy is a double-edged sword. Their patience could pay off if they land the right players, but it could also leave them scrambling to fill critical holes. With seven open scholarship spots and the potential for more to open, the Buckeyes have work to do. But the question remains: Are they moving fast enough to compete for a national title in 2026?
What’s your take? Do you think Ohio State’s approach is the right one, or should they be more aggressive in the portal? Let us know in the comments below!
